K. Parkaran wants readers to believe that one mamak shop pulling down its shutters for Deepavali just exposed the darkest corners of the Malaysian soul.
Let’s get the obvious out of the way before anything else. If a restaurant owner closes for Deepavali so Hindu employees can celebrate with their families, that is decent, fair, and basic good management. Workers deserve their festival leave. And anyone hurling racial slurs or mocking another person’s faith in a comment section deserves every bit of criticism coming their way.
What doesn’t sit right is how Parkaran’s November 16 Free Malaysia Today column, "A mamak shop closes on Deepavali day, and social media erupts", stretches an unnamed internet grumble into a sweeping verdict on Malaysia’s "ugly, tribalistic underbelly"—while leaving out the single most important reason ordinary Muslim diners pause when they see a mamak closed on Deepavali. Here is what the column skips over completely. In Malaysia, the word "mamak" isn’t just shorthand for a 24-hour eatery where people watch football at 3am. It refers specifically to Tamil Muslim restaurants, and Muslim customers walk through those doors relying on an unspoken cultural understanding that the food is halal.
Reply to FMT: Questioning a Mamak Closing on Deepavali Is a Consumer Right— In response to K. Parkaran’s Free Malaysia Today column, "A mamak shop closes on Deepavali day, and social media erupts."
When an uncertified eatery hangs Quranic calligraphy on its walls, puts staff in kopiah, and then closes its doors for a Hindu festival, Muslim consumers naturally stop and ask a simple question: Is this place actually Muslim-run, or does it hold a valid halal certificate?
Asking that question is not religious supremacy, and it certainly isn’t hatred toward Hindus. It is basic consumer diligence.
Malaysia’s own laws recognize why that distinction matters. Under the Trade Descriptions Act 2011 and the Trade Descriptions (Definition of Halal) Order 2011, the Ministry of Domestic Trade and Cost of Living (KPDN) routinely acts against restaurants that display Quranic verses or Islamic symbols without JAKIM halal certification while using non-Muslim food preparers, because doing so misleads Muslim patrons about what they are eating.
At the same time, JAKIM rules explicitly allow non-Muslim-owned eateries to obtain halal certification as long as they meet strict standards, including appointing permanent Malaysian Muslim halal supervisors or staff. That is precisely why clarity matters.
When an eatery skips official certification and leans on Islamic aesthetics instead, customers have every right—both as consumers protected under Malaysian trade law and as Muslims avoiding doubtful (syubhah) food sources to double-check before sitting down to eat.
Instead of dealing with that everyday consumer reality, Parkaran’s column builds an easier opponent to knock down. He reduces the reaction to people allegedly claiming the closure meant "placing Deepavali celebrations over Islam" and treating it like "a betrayal of the social contract".
Sure, comment sections always attract loud trolls. Picking out the loudest, most unhinged internet remark and treating it as the voice of ordinary Malaysians is a textbook strawman. Stranger still is how thin the reporting is underneath all the moralizing.
The column never names the shop, never states where it happened, never identifies the social media platform, and never quotes a single verifiable person or owner. Even the headline quote; "Mamak tutup? On Deepavali?..." has no attribution.
Yet Parkaran presents it as settled fact that the shop closed purely "to allow its staff, many of whom are Hindus, to celebrate".
How could any reader verify that? In past viral discussions on this exact topic, people raised questions precisely because they doubted the eatery was Muslim-owned in the first place.
Assuming the very point in dispute just makes skeptics look foolish by design. Then comes the column’s oddest pivot, where it tries to blame "both sides" of a "never-ending racial culture war". Parkaran writes that one side accused the shop of putting Deepavali above Islam, while the other side "celebrated the closure as a victory for inclusivity, while simultaneously weaponising it against the owners".
How someone praises an owner's decision as inclusive while weaponising it against those same owners is never explained. Without a single example, it reads like a forced attempt to make everyone sound toxic so the columnist can occupy the high ground alone. From there, the leaps only get wider. Anonymous "keyboard warriors" quickly become "we"—meaning an entire country of thirty-plus million people who supposedly "lose our minds" and nurse "deep-seated insecurity".
Twice, Parkaran insists this could "only happen in Malaysia", as if petty social media rows over holiday closures, festive greetings, and religious food norms don’t erupt regularly across Europe, North America, and the rest of Asia. And it is hard to miss the irony of a national columnist spending 600 words diagnosing "scars we inflict on our national psyche" right after scolding Malaysians for blowing "the most trivial of issues" into a national crisis. Parkaran ends by advising anyone bothered by a holiday closure to put down their phone and "reach for a packet of murukku from a Hindu neighbour".
It sounds "warm", but it misses the point entirely. Malaysians have shared Deepavali snacks across neighbourly fences for generations without hesitation. Accepting murukku from a friend you know and trust is one thing; asking whether an uncertified commercial restaurant is using Islamic imagery accurately is another.
We do not have to choose between being good neighbours and being careful consumers. Malaysians can happily celebrate Deepavali with Hindu friends, back employers who give their staff festive leave, and still insist on our right to ask honest questions about halal transparency and the food we buy. Those two things were never in conflict until an opinion piece pretended they were.